Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
A wood-lined covered lanai and bronze-framed glass doors overlook a lush lawn, a fan palm, and flowering gardenias beside a raised stone terrace.

Princeville Golf Course Open Space: What Makai Woods Buyers Should Know

October 22, 2026

The recorded document that has kept Princeville's Woods golf course undeveloped for more than half a century carried an end date of February 28, 2026. That date has now passed. The development restriction is still in force because of a 2025 court ruling, not because of anything the 1972 document says. Honolulu Civil Beat reported in July 2025 that Starwood Capital Group, the Miami-based owner of the golf lands, had argued in court that a ruling for the plaintiffs would have "a profound chilling effect" on title insurers' willingness to do business in Hawaii. Its reason was that no recorded document showed the nondevelopment clause was essentially perpetual despite its stated end date.

For anyone looking at one of the more than 130 Princeville homes next to the former Makai Woods Golf Course, that is the friction worth understanding first. The open space next door is now held in place by a court's reading of two documents together. Starwood has appealed that reading, so a homeowner's view depends on a pending decision.

What the 1972 dedication said, and how the court read it

The governing instrument is the 1972 Dedication of Golf Course Property. According to the Princeville at Hanalei Community Association, it identified the land for golf and related recreational uses through February 28, 2026. Starwood bought the golf course and a nearby hotel in 2018, stopped running the Woods nine as a golf course in 2021, and planned dozens of luxury homes and condominiums on the land to line up with the end of that 55-year nondevelopment provision. The local group Save Open Space Hui says Starwood had announced it would be ready to begin building on March 1, 2026.

Two Princeville residents sued, and in 2025 the Fifth Circuit Court sided with them. Judge Kathleen Watanabe found that the dedication has to be read together with Princeville's 1971 covenants, conditions and restrictions. Under the CC&Rs, the dedication renews automatically in five-year increments unless 75 percent of owners vote otherwise. The association's summary of the ruling says overnight accommodations, glamping, housing development and unapproved ground-disturbing activity are not permitted without appropriate testing, oversight and court approval. The final judgment was signed in August 2025.

The case also raised a historical health issue. Save Open Space Hui reports that Starwood's 2021 glamping application with the Kauai Planning Department revealed a 1917 to 1919 anthrax outbreak on land that later became the Woods nine. The plaintiffs argued that cattle infected decades ago were buried on parts of the property. The community association says the landowner's soil coring and ground-penetrating radar scans have not produced evidence of present-day anthrax, to the association's knowledge. Honolulu Civil Beat reported in February 2025 that the state Department of Health's Kauai office had referred the matter to the state Hazard Evaluation and Emergency Response office, which had discussed it with the CDC and EPA.

Where the case stood after the May 2026 hearing

These are the dates that matter:

  • 2021: Starwood stops operating the Woods nine as a golf course.
  • August 2025: The final judgment bars development and ground-disturbing activity.
  • September 5, 2025: Starwood files its notice of appeal at Hawaii's Intermediate Court of Appeals.
  • February 28, 2026: The dedication's stated end date passes. Under the trial court's ruling, it rolls into a new five-year period.
  • March 1, 2026: Starwood's announced start date for construction passes with the injunction still in place.
  • May 19, 2026: Judge Stephanie Char denies Starwood's request to resume certain ground-disturbing work and keeps the injunction in place while the appeal continues.

Kauai Now reported that Judge Char found too little evidence to justify changing the original injunction. She also noted that the request appeared to seek a modification of the order rather than its enforcement. The appeal was still pending after that hearing.

Why the grass and the law are separate questions

The court decides what can be built on the land. The landowner decides how it is maintained. Kauai Now reported in May that Starwood stopped mowing in summer 2025. The company's position was that even routine maintenance could be read as "ground-disturbing activity" under the court's order. It asked the court to approve a safety plan covering maintenance and access to underground utilities. In the same report, the plaintiffs answered that utility providers already hold access easements on the property.

Judge Char's May ruling settled the narrower point. Routine lawn mowing, landscaping and general maintenance are still allowed on the property. Whether the land is actually being mowed is up to the landowner, not the court. Civil Beat described the course as overgrown as early as February 2025.

The association's position makes the cost picture clearer. The Princeville at Hanalei Community Association says no CC&R amendments that would give the landowner voting rights or assessment obligations are under consideration. Its 2026 Committee is still reviewing safe-work protocols and access rights for utility easement holders, including Kauai Island Utility Cooperative. Nothing in the association's public summary indicates that adjacent owners are being billed for upkeep of the course.

The 75 percent threshold and the land's future

The trial court's reading changes who decides the land's future. Under the judgment, the dedication keeps renewing unless 75 percent of record owners of lots within the association vote to record an instrument ending it. Save Open Space Hui notes that the association's board cannot make that decision alone. It belongs to the owners of land in Princeville 1.

The owners who would have to agree go well beyond the homes along the fairways, and the bar is high. The recorded dedication shows an end date, and the protection beyond that date comes from a court judgment that is under appeal.

Hawaii's seller disclosure law

Hawaii's seller disclosure law defines a "material fact" as any fact, defect or condition, past or present, that would be expected to measurably affect the value of residential real property to a reasonable person. The same statute says the disclosure statement does not replace expert inspection or professional advice. The full definition is in HRS §508D-1. How it applies to a specific home next to the Woods nine is a question for counsel, not for a listing description.

Quick answers

Is the Woods nine going back to golf? The public record shows no plan to reopen it. Starwood stopped operating it as a golf course in 2021, and the litigation concerns development, not golf operations.

Does the ruling cover only the Woods nine? Save Open Space Hui describes the judgment as protecting the entire 27-hole Makai Golf Course. The association refers to the "Makai and Woods Golf Course lands" together.

Could housing still be built there? Under the current judgment, not without testing, government oversight and court approval. The appeal could change that.

This post is general information, not legal, title or financial advice. Anyone weighing a home near the course should confirm the details of their own situation with a real estate attorney and their title company.

The open space behind many Princeville homes is the subject of a court ruling now on appeal. Danette Andrews and the Andrews Collection team have worked in Princeville for more than two decades. Contact Us.

Follow Us On Instagram